rebelwarrior

rebelwarrior

Genetic Algorithms in Elixir: Natural Selection Chp5(p.71)

Hi Sean,

Just go your book and looking it over.

Some bg on me, I’m a ecology and evolutionary major from Princeton, later self-taught programmer. I’ve been noticing a lot of confusion on natural selection related to genetic algorithms just in general.

In general genetic algorithms aren’t based on natural selection but on artificial (human) selection. The big difference is how fitness relates to the outcome. In artificial selection you determine “fitness” a priori, that is before selection, while in evolution “fitness” really is an emergent property. It’s a little weird and that’s why evolution took such a long time to understand.

Darwin’s later adoption of the phrase “survival of the fittest” (which he didn’t coin) is probably the source of this confusion but fitness is not the determinant factor for survival. What? I know. It sounds like the exact opposite of what you’ve heard. But fitness is a property that shows up only after survival. A better way to say it would be “those that survive, tend to be more fit” A tendency that is not deterministic. Can you have the less fit survive? Well technically yes, but more importantly you have no idea what “fit” is until after selection. Remember that natural selection explains the why of speciation. Why there are many species and why they evolve not fitness. Contrast this with artificial or human selection. We breed dogs for certain qualities, we grow plants and select the seed with the qualities we most desire. Here “fitness” is determined by humans before selection, in fact, selection is based on these factors. This seems to be more closely aligned with genetic algorithms to me.

Ok getting back to the book. The following phrase “The fittest individuals are the ones that are selected to reproduce because they can pass their strong genes to the next generation.” on page 71 is technically wrong when referring to natural selection; it is correct when referring to artificial selection.

Nicely this phrase just before it “Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution suggests that strong traits that are key to survival become more common in successive generations.” is correct.

This may seem like a small thing but this misunderstanding of Natural Selection has lead to it being used as a pseudoscientific justification for discrimination in the hands of Social Darwinist, which is really just a pseudoscientific excuse to not be a nice person.

Let me know if you have any questions, happy to discuss.

– David Acevedo

Marked As Solved

seanmor5

seanmor5

Author of Genetic Algorithms in Elixir

Hey David, thanks for the excellent feedback. I see exactly what you’re saying in the sense that using analogies like this can be misleading. Overall, my understanding is that biological/genetic underpinnings in genetic algorithms go little beyond their inspiration. Despite this, I decided it was best to try to use some of these analogies in the hopes that they may be useful in understanding GAs a little better.

To your point, I see exactly how the analogy I used in that circumstance is incorrect, and how that kind of misleading analogy can be harmful. While I won’t be able to fix it before the next beta ships, I will absolutely address it before the final version.

I appreciate your feedback. If you come across any misleading analogies/inconsistencies, feel free to message me or post in here! Thank you for taking the time to make the book better!

Where Next?

Popular Pragmatic Bookshelf topics Top

abtin
page 20: … protoc command… I had to additionally run the following go get commands in order to be able to compile protobuf code using go...
New
jimschubert
In Chapter 3, the source for index introduces Config on page 31, followed by more code including tests; Config isn’t introduced until pag...
New
brianokken
Many tasks_proj/tests directories exist in chapters 2, 3, 5 that have tests that use the custom markers smoke and get, which are not decl...
New
Alexandr
Hi everyone! There is an error on the page 71 in the book “Programming machine learning from coding to depp learning” P. Perrotta. You c...
New
mikecargal
Title: Hands-on Rust: question about get_component (page 295) (feel free to respond. “You dug you’re own hole… good luck”) I have somet...
New
raul
Page 28: It implements io.ReaderAt on the store type. Sorry if it’s a dumb question but was the io.ReaderAt supposed to be io.ReadAt? ...
New
jeremyhuiskamp
Title: Web Development with Clojure, Third Edition, vB17.0 (p9) The create table guestbook syntax suggested doesn’t seem to be accepted ...
New
brunogirin
When I run the coverage example to report on missing lines, I get: pytest --cov=cards --report=term-missing ch7 ERROR: usage: pytest [op...
New
brunogirin
When installing Cards as an editable package, I get the following error: ERROR: File “setup.py” not found. Directory cannot be installe...
New
New

Other popular topics Top

Devtalk
Hello Devtalk World! Please let us know a little about who you are and where you’re from :nerd_face:
New
AstonJ
What chair do you have while working… and why? Is there a ‘best’ type of chair or working position for developers?
New
malloryerik
Any thoughts on Svelte? Svelte is a radical new approach to building user interfaces. Whereas traditional frameworks like React and Vue...
New
axelson
I’ve been really enjoying obsidian.md: It is very snappy (even though it is based on Electron). I love that it is all local by defaul...
New
AstonJ
Thanks to @foxtrottwist’s and @Tomas’s posts in this thread: Poll: Which code editor do you use? I bought Onivim! :nerd_face: https://on...
New
Rainer
Not sure if following fits exactly this thread, or if we should have a hobby thread… For many years I’m designing and building model air...
New
Exadra37
I am asking for any distro that only has the bare-bones to be able to get a shell in the server and then just install the packages as we ...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Create efficient, elegant software tests in pytest, Python's most powerful testing framework. Brian Okken @brianokken Edited by Kat...
New
AstonJ
Saw this on TikTok of all places! :lol: Anyone heard of them before? Lite:
New
DevotionGeo
I have always used antique keyboards like Cherry MX 1800 or Cherry MX 8100 and almost always have modified the switches in some way, like...
New

Sub Categories: