jamis

jamis

Author of Mazes for Programmers and 1 other title

The Ray Tracer Challenge: various errata

The following is cross-posted from the original Ray Tracer Challenge forum, from a post by garfieldnate. I’m cross-posting it so that the errata can be kept in a single place.

Original post here: https://forum.raytracerchallenge.com/thread/203/performance-tips-clarifications-book-errata

Possible/Definite Errata

These are points where following the book exactly caused incorrect behavior in my implementation.

  • The “A ray misses a cube” test needs one more case: the ray is cast away from the cube. Not implementing this will make cubes always appear in front of the camera, even if placed behind it. Here is another test case where the ray should miss the cube:

|point(0, 0, 2) | vector(0, 0, 1)|

Fixing the book’s algorithm: at the end of the method, if tmax is negative then no intersection should be reported. The algorithm given in the book allows tmax to be a negative number, indicating an intersection opposite the ray’s direction.

  • Cylinder cap intersection should NOT have object_ray.direction.y <= REALLY_SMALL_POSITIVE_NUMBER as a quick return.
  • Cone and cylinder side intersections required checking a.abs() and b.abs() against REALLY_SMALL_POSITIVE_NUMBER; exact checking against 0 did not work at all.
  • For the second test case given for “Intersecting a cone with a ray”, I had to change -5 to -4.999999 to get the ray to intersect with the cone.
  • The cylinder azimuth calculation should be performed with x and z, not x and y.
  • Bonus bounding box chapter: there is no bounding box specified for smooth triangles; though I did not end up implementing this, I’m certain the algorithm has to be different from that used for regular triangles.
  • Bonus UV mapping chapter: the provided cross diagram for UV mapping of a cube is wrong for up and down
  • Up and down should both map x positively. The tests are correct. I found another chart with the correct mapping on wikipedia: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cube_mapping#/media/File:Cube_map.svg, but it also makes intuitive sense. Looking up or down from inside the cube, the observer’s x never reverses from the absolute x.

Clarifications

  • In the cone section: “If a is nonzero, you’ll use the same algorithm, but with the new a, b, and c, that you used for the cylinders.” I found this sentence confusing and it took a while to understand it. I think it would be more clearly written like so: “If a is nonzero, you’ll use the same algorithm (but with the new a, b, and c) that you used for the cylinders.”
  • Where UV mappers use mod/%, a note should be made that there are several related operations that a programming language might represent with %; particularly, be careful to choose an implementation that always return positive values, even if the input is negative. See the treatment on Wikipedia here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modulo_operation#In_programming_languages. In Rust, I needed to use the rem_euclid function instead of the % operator.
  • There isn’t any note in the UV chapter on how a cylinder has to be scaled for the texture to look correct, though Jamis demonstrates it in the provided scene YAMLs. As I found a similar issue reported on StackOverflow, I ended up doing a little writeup there to explain the issue and how to fix it: stackoverflow.com/a/60913088/474819
  • Test “Converting a point from world to object space” should scale by 1,2,3 instead of 2,2,2 to catch more programming errors.

Typos/Small Errata

These will only really be useful for Jamis :)

  • Typo in bounding boxes chapter: inculde -> include
  • Pseudocode for CubeMap’s pattern_at contains uv_cube_left, etc. but these should be cube_uv_left, etc. to be consistent with the previous declarations in the chapter
  • There are two scenarios named “Checker pattern in 2D” in the UV mapping chapter. The second one should probably be “UV mapping an image” or something like that.
  • Typo in UV chapter: “Experiment and see what you come up.” (missing “with”)
  • “non-cubic bounding box” is not a great name for the test in the bounding box chapter; maybe “bounding box not centered at origin” would be clearer.

Most Liked

PetroCoder

PetroCoder

In these two tests (p222 and p223):

Scenario: A smooth triangle uses u/v to interpolate the normal
  When i ← intersection_with_uv(1, tri, 0.45, 0.25)

Scenario: Preparing the normal on a smooth triangle
  When i ← intersection_with_uv(1, tri, 0.45, 0.25)

The first parameter t should be qual to 2. The ray intersects the triangle at distance 2, according to my calculations. Could this be an error?

jamis

jamis

Author of Mazes for Programmers and 1 other title

Hello!

For these two tests, there are no rays being cast—all we’re doing here is creating an intersection record which we’re arbitrarily saying exists at t=1. You could set t=2, but it would make no difference, because the normal calculation is independent of t. For these smooth triangles, the only parameters that matter are u and v (and, of course, the triangle itself).

Does that make sense? Is there something I could be describing better?

Thanks!

Jamis

PetroCoder

PetroCoder

Hi Jamis,

Thank you for this explanation. It makes perfect sense. In my code, I am also checking (just in case) that all parameters of the intersection are “consistent”, i.e. that there is indeed an intersection with the object at a given value of t. That is why I have spotted this case.

Kind regards,
Petro

Popular Pragmatic Bookshelf topics Top

Razor54672
The answer to 3rd Problem of Chapter 5 (Making Choices) of “Practical Programming, Third Edition” seems incorrect in the given answer ke...
New
jesse050717
Title: Web Development with Clojure, Third Edition, pg 116 Hi - I just started chapter 5 and I am stuck on page 116 while trying to star...
New
rmurray10127
Title: Intuitive Python: docker run… denied error (page 2) Attempted to run the docker command in both CLI and Powershell PS C:\Users\r...
New
leba0495
Hello! Thanks for the great book. I was attempting the Trie (chap 17) exercises and for number 4 the solution provided for the autocorre...
New
fynn
This is as much a suggestion as a question, as a note for others. Locally the SGP30 wasn’t available, so I ordered a SGP40. On page 53, ...
New
nicoatridge
Hi, I have just acquired Michael Fazio’s “Kotlin and Android Development” to learn about game programming for Android. I have a game in p...
New
digitalbias
Title: Build a Weather Station with Elixir and Nerves: Problem connecting to Postgres with Grafana on (page 64) If you follow the defau...
New
adamwoolhether
Is there any place where we can discuss the solutions to some of the exercises? I can figure most of them out, but am having trouble with...
New
creminology
Skimming ahead, much of the following is explained in Chapter 3, but new readers (like me!) will hit a roadblock in Chapter 2 with their ...
New
jwandekoken
Book: Programming Phoenix LiveView, page 142 (157/378), file lib/pento_web/live/product_live/form_component.ex, in the function below: d...
New

Other popular topics Top

Devtalk
Hello Devtalk World! Please let us know a little about who you are and where you’re from :nerd_face:
New
AstonJ
If it’s a mechanical keyboard, which switches do you have? Would you recommend it? Why? What will your next keyboard be? Pics always w...
New
brentjanderson
Bought the Moonlander mechanical keyboard. Cherry Brown MX switches. Arms and wrists have been hurting enough that it’s time I did someth...
New
Rainer
My first contact with Erlang was about 2 years ago when I used RabbitMQ, which is written in Erlang, for my job. This made me curious and...
New
Rainer
Not sure if following fits exactly this thread, or if we should have a hobby thread… For many years I’m designing and building model air...
New
dimitarvp
Small essay with thoughts on macOS vs. Linux: I know @Exadra37 is just waiting around the corner to scream at me “I TOLD YOU SO!!!” but I...
New
AstonJ
Seems like a lot of people caught it - just wondered whether any of you did? As far as I know I didn’t, but it wouldn’t surprise me if I...
New
foxtrottwist
A few weeks ago I started using Warp a terminal written in rust. Though in it’s current state of development there are a few caveats (tab...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Author Spotlight: Peter Ullrich @PJUllrich Data is at the core of every business, but it is useless if nobody can access and analyze ...
New
AstonJ
This is cool! DEEPSEEK-V3 ON M4 MAC: BLAZING FAST INFERENCE ON APPLE SILICON We just witnessed something incredible: the largest open-s...
New