jrinaldi

jrinaldi

Effective Haskell: wrong definition of sumOfUniques (page 393 on Kindle)

@RebeccaSkinner

Currently, it is:

sumOfUniques n = ​ foldr (add n) (additiveIdentity n) . unique n

It should be:

sumOfUniques n = ​ foldr add additiveIdentity . unique n

Marked As Solved

jrinaldi

jrinaldi

Hi Rebecca,

Thank you very much for the detailed explanation. Sorry, the example is actually correct.

I was missing the fact that equal and additiveIdentity are actually field selectors. Instead, I thought they were the fields: types a -> a -> Bool and a, respectively. That would have been the case if the Natural a would have been pattern-matched against Natural{..} by enabling the RecordWildCards extension.

Also Liked

RebeccaSkinner

RebeccaSkinner

Author of Effective Haskell

Hi!

Are you seeing an error? I believe this example should be correct. Remember than in example we’re using our own definition of Natural - a record that contains functions that tell us how to do arithmetic:

data Natural a = Natural
{ equal :: a -> a -> Bool
, add : a -> a -> a
, multiply :: a -> a -> a
, additiveIdentity :: a
, multiplicativeIdentity :: a
, displayAsString :: a -> String
}

We’ll call sumOfUniques by giving it some particular definition of natural numbers, for example intNatural or peanoNatural. Here’s an example of how we might call it:

λ sumOfUniques intNatural [1..10]
55

In this example, we’re passing in intNatural, which tells us how to do these operations on Int values. Its’ defined like this:

intNatural :: Natural Int
intNatural = Natural
  { equal = (==)
  , add = (+)
  , multiply = (*)
  , additiveIdentity = 0
  , multiplicativeIdentity = 1
  , displayAsString = show
  }

If we substitute intNatural for nn in our example, we’d end up with something like this:

foldr (add intNatural) (additiveIdentity intNatural) . unique intNatural

You can see here that we’re accessing the functions inside of our Natural record and passing them in as arguments to foldr. If we expaned this out another layer, it’ll make a bit more sense:

-- First, remember that
add intNatural = (+)
additiveIdentity intNatural = 0

-- so
foldr (add intNatural) (additiveIdentity intNatural) . unique intNatural
-- is the same as
foldr (+) 0 . unique intNatural

Later, once we refactor Natural to be a type class instead of a record, we won’t need to explicitly pass around n at all, since that will be part of the constraint in our type class. In that case, we can imagine that our definition would be something like:

sumOfUniques :: Natural n => [n] -> n
sumOfUniques = foldr add additiveIdentity . unique

Where Next?

Popular Pragmatic Bookshelf topics Top

jdufour
Hello! On page xix of the preface, it says there is a community forum "… for help if your’re stuck on one of the exercises in this book… ...
New
joepstender
The generated iex result below should list products instead of product for the metadata. (page 67) iex> product = %Product{} %Pento....
New
gilesdotcodes
In case this helps anyone, I’ve had issues setting up the rails source code. Here were the solutions: In Gemfile, change gem 'rails' t...
New
leonW
I ran this command after installing the sample application: $ cards add do something --owner Brian And got a file not found error: Fil...
New
patoncrispy
I’m new to Rust and am using this book to learn more as well as to feed my interest in game dev. I’ve just finished the flappy dragon exa...
New
jskubick
I found an issue in Chapter 7 regarding android:backgroundTint vs app:backgroundTint. How to replicate: load chapter-7 from zipfile i...
New
brunogirin
When trying to run tox in parallel as explained on page 151, I got the following error: tox: error: argument -p/–parallel: expected one...
New
brunogirin
When running tox for the first time, I got the following error: ERROR: InterpreterNotFound: python3.10 I realised that I was running ...
New
ggerico
I got this error when executing the plot files on macOS Ventura 13.0.1 with Python 3.10.8 and matplotlib 3.6.1: programming_ML/code/03_...
New
davetron5000
Hello faithful readers! If you have tried to follow along in the book, you are asked to start up the dev environment via dx/build and ar...
New

Other popular topics Top

PragmaticBookshelf
Learn from the award-winning programming series that inspired the Elixir language, and go on a step-by-step journey through the most impo...
New
brentjanderson
Bought the Moonlander mechanical keyboard. Cherry Brown MX switches. Arms and wrists have been hurting enough that it’s time I did someth...
New
New
AstonJ
I have seen the keycaps I want - they are due for a group-buy this week but won’t be delivered until October next year!!! :rofl: The Ser...
New
dimitarvp
Small essay with thoughts on macOS vs. Linux: I know @Exadra37 is just waiting around the corner to scream at me “I TOLD YOU SO!!!” but I...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Tailwind CSS is an exciting new CSS framework that allows you to design your site by composing simple utility classes to create complex e...
New
mafinar
This is going to be a long an frequently posted thread. While talking to a friend of mine who has taken data structure and algorithm cou...
New
AstonJ
If you want a quick and easy way to block any website on your Mac using Little Snitch simply… File > New Rule: And select Deny, O...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Author Spotlight: VM Brasseur @vmbrasseur We have a treat for you today! We turn the spotlight onto Open Source as we sit down with V...
New
Margaret
Ask Me Anything with Mark Volkmann @mvolkmann On February 24 and 25, we are giving you a chance to ask questions of PragProg author M...
New

Sub Categories: