Fl4m3Ph03n1x

Fl4m3Ph03n1x

How to get the top X results of a given category using Ecto?

Background

I have to queries that return a colossal amount of data on their own. I cannot use Repo.all as doing so would materialize these into memory, which would then quickly run out.

So I am trying to push as much as I can to the pSQL DB, and force the DB to do as much work as possible.

My issue starts with 2 queries.

This ones counts fruits and veggies and aggregates everything into a neat map.

all_counts =
      table_A
      |> join(:left, [item_A], item_B in table_B,
        on:
          item_A.home_id == item_B.home_id and
            item_A.path == item_B.path
      )
      |> select([unfiltered_item, filtered_item], %{
        path: item_A.path,
        item_fruits_count: coalesce(item_A.fruits, 0),
        item_veggies_count: coalesce(item_B.veggies, 0),
        dataset_id: item_A.home_id
      })
      |> subquery()

The second one, joins 2 tables as well (items and photos), with nothing fancy:

file_info =
      table_C
      |> join(:inner, [item], file in table_D,
        on:
          item.id == file.item_id and not file.deleted
      )
      |> select([item, file], %{
        item_id: item.id,
        home_id: item.home_id,
        path: item.path,
        photo_key: file.photo_key
      })
      |> subquery()

Problem

Now the problem is that I need to merge these 2 together.
At first, one would think to do something like this:

result =
      all_counts
      |> join(:inner, [c], f in ^file_info, on: c.home_id == f.home_id and c.path == f.path)
      |> select([c, f], %{
        item_id: f.item_id,
        home_id: f.home_id,
        path: f.path,
        photo_key: f.photo_key,
        # ... you get the idea
      })
      |> Repo.all()

But this creates an issue, namely, the it will return so much data, the machines will run out of memory.

Approach

The approach I am using to solve this problem is to group items by home_id and path (since that is unique for each destination) and then return only a portion of the data I need, lets say, the top 3 items ordered by id.

Source:

Here is where my difficulties begin.
I cannot use pSQL directly, I must use Ecto (for reasons beyond this post).

Normally I would use CTEs or row_number():

With ctes:

 WITH cte AS
  ( SELECT name, value,
           ROW_NUMBER() OVER (PARTITION BY name
                              ORDER BY value DESC
                             )
             AS rn
    FROM t
  )
SELECT name, value, rn
FROM cte
WHERE rn <= 3
ORDER BY name, rn ;

With row_number:

SELECT name, value, rn
FROM 
  ( SELECT name, value,
           ROW_NUMBER() OVER (PARTITION BY name
                              ORDER BY value DESC
                             )
             AS rn
    FROM t
  ) tmp 
WHERE rn <= 3
ORDER BY name, rn ; 

However, I am not familiar enough with Ecto to know how to use them.

With CTEs, I understand I should avoid them, as they serve no purpose in Ecto:
https://hexdocs.pm/ecto/Ecto.Query.html#with_cte/3

With row_number() I would need to partition by both home_id and path (2 fields) instead of one:
https://hexdocs.pm/ecto/Ecto.Query.WindowAPI.html#row_number/0

Question

How do I get the result, to return the top 3 results, grouped by home_id and path and ordered by item_id using Ecto?

Marked As Solved

Fl4m3Ph03n1x

Fl4m3Ph03n1x

Solution(s)

From what I gathered, there are two decent possible solutions to this conundrum.

row_number + over

One of them is using row_number() with over() from Ecto:
https://hexdocs.pm/ecto/Ecto.Query.WindowAPI.html#row_number/0

Assuming I join both file_info with all_counts in a single table, I can then perform the query as mentioned in the previous SO post I mentioned in my question:

file_info_with_counts
|> select([fi], %{
        rn: over(row_number(), partition_by: [fi.home_id, fi.path], order_by: [asc: fi.item_id]),
        item_id: fi.item_id,
       # you get the idea ...
      })
|> subquery()

IO.inspect(file_info_with_counts |> where([c], c.rn <= 3) |> Repo.all()

Which prints what I wanted.

Source:

Lateral inner joins

However, as mentioned by some people in the community, this solution is rather old, and these days lateral joins seem to also cover this use case.

tops = 
  from top in "file_info_with_counts", 
    where: top.home_id == parent_as(:parent).home_id,
    where: top.path == parent_as(:parent).path,
    order_by: [asc: top.item_id],
    limit: 3,
    select: %{id: top.id}

from parent in "file_info_with_counts",
  as: :parent,
  group_by: [parent.home_id, parent.path],
  lateral_join: top in subquery(tops), 
  on: true,
  select: %{home_id: parent.home_id, path: parent.path, item_id: top.id}

Source:

This solution is not without merit, however, given my familiarity with row_number I opted for that solution instead.

Unless there is a considerable performance difference between the two in favor of lateral joins, I will keep the previous solution.

For more info, here is the original source where I got these answers:

Also Liked

andrea

andrea

Will Ecto be able to support NoSQL databases in the future?

Fl4m3Ph03n1x

Fl4m3Ph03n1x

While I am not an expert, I believe there is a package called mongodb_ecto:

So if you use MongoDB, this might be your thing.

Where Next?

Popular Backend topics Top

ohm
Does anybody have good learning resources with regards to going into Event Driven Design, Architecture or Sourcing? I got recommended Er...
New
Jsdr3398
I’ve been working on and rewriting my messaging platform several times for the past two years. With Discords new rebranding, it has reall...
New
Ookma-Kyi
I am learning Elixir at the moment but am finding it difficult to learn. The issue is there aren’t any good tutorial sites out there when...
New
JimmyCarterSon
Hello, I am. very new to Elixir lang I have only been doing it for about 2 weeks. I recently started following this tutorial todo list, ...
New
Fl4m3Ph03n1x
Background I am trying to encode a structure into json format using the Jason library. However, this is not working as expected. Code L...
New
conradwt
Hi, I’m building an application that will have support for both the web and mobile. At this time, I’m using PhxGenAuth for authenticatio...
New
osbre
Hello everyone I’m trying to implement a “magic link” or “one-time login link” functionality I wonder what a secure way to implement it...
New
Fl4m3Ph03n1x
Background PS: the following situation describes an hypothetical scenario, where I own a company that sells things to customers. I have ...
New
jaeyson
Hi! I have clarifications (please correct me, as I mostly mix/confuse this details) with the following: The term RAG here where it read...
New
AstonJ
If you’re getting errors like this: psql: error: connection to server on socket “/tmp/.s.PGSQL.5432” failed: No such file or directory ...
New

Other popular topics Top

AstonJ
If it’s a mechanical keyboard, which switches do you have? Would you recommend it? Why? What will your next keyboard be? Pics always w...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Ruby, Io, Prolog, Scala, Erlang, Clojure, Haskell. With Seven Languages in Seven Weeks, by Bruce A. Tate, you’ll go beyond the syntax—and...
New
Exadra37
I am thinking in building or buy a desktop computer for programing, both professionally and on my free time, and my choice of OS is Linux...
New
AstonJ
poll poll Be sure to check out @Dusty’s article posted here: An Introduction to Alternative Keyboard Layouts It’s one of the best write-...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
From finance to artificial intelligence, genetic algorithms are a powerful tool with a wide array of applications. But you don't need an ...
New
New
DevotionGeo
The V Programming Language Simple language for building maintainable programs V is already mentioned couple of times in the forum, but I...
New
husaindevelop
Inside our android webview app, we are trying to paste the copied content from another app eg (notes) using navigator.clipboard.readtext ...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Leverage Elixir and the Nx ecosystem to build intelligent applications that solve real-world problems in computer vision, natural languag...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Escape callback hell and ship fast, clean code that reads as smoothly as it runs. Squash bugs and stamp out memory leaks with an intuitiv...
New