dylanmc

dylanmc

Rust Brain Teasers: "Stacking Boxes" heap vs. stack performance explanation

Title: Rust Brain Teasers, page 47

“Because of the extra steps required for heap read/write access—particularly with frequent allocations—accessing data on the heap can be a lot slower than accessing data on the stack. Why? Because the CPU’s memory cache will try its best to keep your heap data available.”

This explanation doesn’t really make sense - both heap and stack are cached, and in both cases “the memory cache will try its best”. I think this might be trying to say something about stack memory has better locality, so the cache has an easier job, but even so, the above paragraph struck me as misleading and/or confusing.

Marked As Solved

herbert

herbert

Author of Hands-on Rust

Thank you! I’m inclined to agree, I’ll see if I can make that explanation a bit clearer for the next beta.

There’s really two things at play with stack vs. heap cache. One is locality: your stack is almost always in one of the cache levels because your program uses it constantly. The stack being tiny also helps with this: it’s easy to fit into the cache, so there’s an even higher probability that it will be there (and if it isn’t, it’s a fast operation to load a tiny stack frame into cache vs. an arbitrarily sized heap object).

Good catch - thank you. :slight_smile:

Also Liked

dylanmc

dylanmc

Yay - glad to help! While I’m here, I think the previous paragraph is also confusing:

“Reading data from the heap also requires a little more work: to read data, your program first needs to read the pointer to determine where the heap data is stored. Once it knows the location, the program can read the data from there.”

It’s confusing (to me) - accessing the stack is also via a pointer, and usually accessing the stack involves computing an offset from the stack pointer first, so…it’s not cut-and-dried easier.

One aspect of the difference between them that your discussion doesn’t yet capture is that allocating from the stack is super-cheap (moving the SP), where it’s almost rocket science what goes on in modern heap allocators.

I’m really enjoying the book so far - I’ve learned a lot already!

Where Next?

Popular Pragmatic Bookshelf topics Top

abtin
page 20: … protoc command… I had to additionally run the following go get commands in order to be able to compile protobuf code using go...
New
jamis
The following is cross-posted from the original Ray Tracer Challenge forum, from a post by garfieldnate. I’m cross-posting it so that the...
New
herminiotorres
Hi! I know not the intentions behind this narrative when called, on page XI: mount() |> handle_event() |> render() but the correc...
New
AndyDavis3416
@noelrappin Running the webpack dev server, I receive the following warning: ERROR in tsconfig.json TS18003: No inputs were found in c...
New
fynn
This is as much a suggestion as a question, as a note for others. Locally the SGP30 wasn’t available, so I ordered a SGP40. On page 53, ...
New
brunogirin
When I run the coverage example to report on missing lines, I get: pytest --cov=cards --report=term-missing ch7 ERROR: usage: pytest [op...
New
Charles
In general, the book isn’t yet updated for Phoenix version 1.6. On page 18 of the book, the authors indicate that an auto generated of ro...
New
mert
AWDWR 7, page 152, page 153: Hello everyone, I’m a little bit lost on the hotwire part. I didn’t fully understand it. On page 152 @rub...
New
Henrai
Hi, I’m working on the Chapter 8 of the book. After I add add the point_offset, I’m still able to see acne: In the image above, I re...
New
bjnord
Hello @herbert ! Trying to get the very first “Hello, Bracket Terminal!" example to run (p. 53). I develop on an Amazon EC2 instance runn...
New

Other popular topics Top

PragmaticBookshelf
Learn from the award-winning programming series that inspired the Elixir language, and go on a step-by-step journey through the most impo...
New
AstonJ
You might be thinking we should just ask who’s not using VSCode :joy: however there are some new additions in the space that might give V...
New
AstonJ
I’ve been hearing quite a lot of comments relating to the sound of a keyboard, with one of the most desirable of these called ‘thock’, he...
New
AstonJ
Continuing the discussion from Thinking about learning Crystal, let’s discuss - I was wondering which languages don’t GC - maybe we can c...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Author Spotlight Jamis Buck @jamis This month, we have the pleasure of spotlighting author Jamis Buck, who has written Mazes for Prog...
New
Help
I am trying to crate a game for the Nintendo switch, I wanted to use Java as I am comfortable with that programming language. Can you use...
New
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Explore the power of Ash Framework by modeling and building the domain for a real-world web application. Rebecca Le @sevenseacat and ...
New
AstonJ
This is a very quick guide, you just need to: Download LM Studio: https://lmstudio.ai/ Click on search Type DeepSeek, then select the o...
New
AstonJ
Curious what kind of results others are getting, I think actually prefer the 7B model to the 32B model, not only is it faster but the qua...
New

Sub Categories: