dylanmc

dylanmc

Rust Brain Teasers: "Stacking Boxes" heap vs. stack performance explanation

Title: Rust Brain Teasers, page 47

“Because of the extra steps required for heap read/write access—particularly with frequent allocations—accessing data on the heap can be a lot slower than accessing data on the stack. Why? Because the CPU’s memory cache will try its best to keep your heap data available.”

This explanation doesn’t really make sense - both heap and stack are cached, and in both cases “the memory cache will try its best”. I think this might be trying to say something about stack memory has better locality, so the cache has an easier job, but even so, the above paragraph struck me as misleading and/or confusing.

Marked As Solved

herbert

herbert

Author of Hands-on Rust

Thank you! I’m inclined to agree, I’ll see if I can make that explanation a bit clearer for the next beta.

There’s really two things at play with stack vs. heap cache. One is locality: your stack is almost always in one of the cache levels because your program uses it constantly. The stack being tiny also helps with this: it’s easy to fit into the cache, so there’s an even higher probability that it will be there (and if it isn’t, it’s a fast operation to load a tiny stack frame into cache vs. an arbitrarily sized heap object).

Good catch - thank you. :slight_smile:

Also Liked

dylanmc

dylanmc

Yay - glad to help! While I’m here, I think the previous paragraph is also confusing:

“Reading data from the heap also requires a little more work: to read data, your program first needs to read the pointer to determine where the heap data is stored. Once it knows the location, the program can read the data from there.”

It’s confusing (to me) - accessing the stack is also via a pointer, and usually accessing the stack involves computing an offset from the stack pointer first, so…it’s not cut-and-dried easier.

One aspect of the difference between them that your discussion doesn’t yet capture is that allocating from the stack is super-cheap (moving the SP), where it’s almost rocket science what goes on in modern heap allocators.

I’m really enjoying the book so far - I’ve learned a lot already!

Where Next?

Popular Pragmatic Bookshelf topics Top

jon
Some minor things in the paper edition that says “3 2020” on the title page verso, not mentioned in the book’s errata online: p. 186 But...
New
johnp
Running the examples in chapter 5 c under pytest 5.4.1 causes an AttributeError: ‘module’ object has no attribute ‘config’. In particula...
New
simonpeter
When I try the command to create a pair of migration files I get an error. user=> (create-migration "guestbook") Execution error (Ill...
New
lirux
Hi Jamis, I think there’s an issue with a test on chapter 6. I own the ebook, version P1.0 Feb. 2019. This test doesn’t pass for me: ...
New
jeremyhuiskamp
Title: Web Development with Clojure, Third Edition, vB17.0 (p9) The create table guestbook syntax suggested doesn’t seem to be accepted ...
New
brian-m-ops
#book-python-testing-with-pytest-second-edition Hi. Thanks for writing the book. I am just learning so this might just of been an issue ...
New
patoncrispy
I’m new to Rust and am using this book to learn more as well as to feed my interest in game dev. I’ve just finished the flappy dragon exa...
New
jgchristopher
“The ProductLive.Index template calls a helper function, live_component/3, that in turn calls on the modal component. ” Excerpt From: Br...
New
redconfetti
Docker-Machine became part of the Docker Toolbox, which was deprecated in 2020, long after Docker Desktop supported Docker Engine nativel...
New
SlowburnAZ
Getting an error when installing the dependencies at the start of this chapter: could not compile dependency :exla, "mix compile" failed...
New

Other popular topics Top

PragmaticBookshelf
Andy and Dave wrote this influential, classic book to help their clients create better software and rediscover the joy of coding. Almost ...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Write Elixir tests that you can be proud of. Dive into Elixir’s test philosophy and gain mastery over the terminology and concepts that u...
New
Rainer
My first contact with Erlang was about 2 years ago when I used RabbitMQ, which is written in Erlang, for my job. This made me curious and...
New
dimitarvp
Small essay with thoughts on macOS vs. Linux: I know @Exadra37 is just waiting around the corner to scream at me “I TOLD YOU SO!!!” but I...
New
Maartz
Hi folks, I don’t know if I saw this here but, here’s a new programming language, called Roc Reminds me a bit of Elm and thus Haskell. ...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Leverage Elixir and the Nx ecosystem to build intelligent applications that solve real-world problems in computer vision, natural languag...
New
sir.laksmana_wenk
I’m able to do the “artistic” part of game-development; character designing/modeling, music, environment modeling, etc. However, I don’t...
New
AstonJ
If you’re getting errors like this: psql: error: connection to server on socket “/tmp/.s.PGSQL.5432” failed: No such file or directory ...
New
PragmaticBookshelf
Escape callback hell and ship fast, clean code that reads as smoothly as it runs. Squash bugs and stamp out memory leaks with an intuitiv...
New
xiji2646-netizen
Woke up to this today: Claude Code’s complete source code exposed via npm source map. Not a snippet. All 512,000 lines. 1,900 TypeScript ...
New

Sub Categories: